| |
J.M.Piel in DIAPASON March 2006
Index
|
| | | | | | | | The best transformer ever?
Click here to enlarge
Translation
The best transformer ever?
The
price of a very good CD-player for a simple MC-transformer! Crazy,
you'll say. A product like this is certainly only made for audiophiles
or hifi maniacs dedicated to vinyl, possessing an excellent turntable
or even an excellent preamplifier. In fact we are speaking about a
transformer of rarely to find qualities, made for cartridges with low
impedance like for example Ortofon. We have made the test with a
cartridge of Shindo Laboratory mounted on a Shindo tonearm,
amplification was Shindo preamp "Catherine" and Shindo poweramp "300 B
Limited" with Tannoy "Gold" speakers of the first generation. We
compared the transformer to some others of highest reputation (Shindo
"Arome", Ortofon MC 3000, new Denon "pro").
After two months of audition we were sure that there is no way back, never before had we listened this way...
Without
exaggeration we can say that it was simply the rediscovery of our vinyl
collection, in fact this transformer literally transcends the
cartridge. It delievers an unbelievable open tone with respect to both
dynamics and musicality. The listening becomes a moving experience. In
comparison to the competitors like the Shindo "Arome" or the Ortofon
3000, the Hommage T1 gives the impression instruments have more
physical realism, the keystroke of the pianist is more distinctive, the
play more authentic, vivid, expressive. The wonderful recording of
Tchaikovski's Concerto for Violon with Szering and Haitink (Philips)
makes one believe in a better reading of the cartridge that extracts
informations never being heard before.
A fortissimo enfolds
unlimited and without diminution of the orchestral image, almost
without dynamical limitations, the limit of saturation appears to be
moved extremely high. The other transformers - as excellent as they are
- give the impression that the music is losing respiration, swing,
extension, it suddenly appears more static, less nuanced, more flat in
rythm and expansion - briefly said, the music seems likewise poorer and
less ordered.
Of course, it requires a system and especially a
preamp that is capable of making the differences audible. But for sure
this transformer is a milestone and joins immediately the mythical
products in the history of hifidelity. For us it is not only the best
transformer, it also means a new definition of the musical
possibilities in analog reproduction. The one regret: it's made only
for cartridges with low impedance, let's hope that Ortofon will keep on
the production for yet a long time.
Jean Marie Piel, Paris Diapason March 2006
| |
|
|